Propolis as Ecological Medicine

By James Fearnley – Nature’s Laboratory

Scientific research over the last 60 years has more than confirmed Aristotle’s inspired naming of the substance honeybees used to defend the colony; Propolis – Pro – Polis – before the city or Defender of the City.   

Marla Spivak’s work in Minnesota has illustrated how propolis provides both physical and social immunity or defence for the bee colony. Physically, propolis is used to both build and control the entrance to the hive, defending the hive against invaders. Socially, propolis provides social hygiene within the colony- bee to bee – managing, controlling and balancing ( we might call it sterilising) the external surface level of microorganisms within the hive.  

But propolis also helps with immune defence in a more inner and existential way. It does this by providing uniquely appropriate pharmacological management of potentially dangerous microorganisms within each individual honeybee within the hive. In this sense propolis provides threefold immunity for the bee colony – outer physical Immunity, Interior hygienic social immunity for the superorganism and internally for each bee, pharmacological defence or immunity. 

Threefold Immunity for the Honeybee

This threefold picture of immunity for the honeybee has evolved out of a remarkable relationship between the honeybee and the plant world that forms part of its local ecology. The honeybee selects and collects resins available from local trees and plants. In so doing the honeybee takes and transforms the plants immune response mechanism- the resins – and converts and transforms them within the hive into its own. In this relationship local plant ecology is integrated, one may say elevated, into the honeybee’s unique immune defence system. The honeybee by selectively accessing the local plant world’s unique ecological defence complements and evolves its own unique ecologically centred immunity. 

Ecology- Uniqueness – Immunity  

Unique ecology and unique immunity go together. We know from the hundreds of papers produced about the complex chemistry of propolis– potentially up to 400 different chemicals – that its composition varies radically depending on climate, flora and many other factors. This complex and unique blend of chemicals has frustrated the traditional chemists’ search as for a standardised propolis and for those elusive essentials of pharmaceutical medicine – key active components.  

Health, it seems is immunity and immunity is rooted in unique ecology i.e. unique chemistry. The honeybee in Brazil accesses a vastly different local/ecological chemistry to build immunity than does the honeybee in Belgium. 
Can propolis then ever be a classic medicine, can it ever fit into the scientific straight jacket of modern symptom related, targeted, synthetic standardised pharmaceutical medicine.  

The changing face of medicine 

Propolis has been used as a medicine since time immemorial. But what is medicine? The definition has changed radically over the ages. In Egyptian times medicine was practiced by the priests. It certainly involved material substances, but more importantly medicine for the Egyptians involved the help and support of the Gods.    

Hippocrates the founder of modern western medicine defined medicine as an “Art composed of the patient, the disease and the doctor”. Medicine for Hippocrates was less about physical substances and more about relationship- relationship between the 1. Physical – The Disease, 2. The Social – The Patient and 3. The Spiritual – The Doctor.  

Turning to the present day – the UK’s MHRA – (Medicines and Healthcare Regulatory Authority) defines medicine as “A substance ….  designed to treat prevent or cure disease ….”. We have moved from a three-dimensional definition of medicine to one dimension i.e. the physical substance and of course linear concepts of cause and effect.  

However, current trends in the development of what is now being called complementary medicine or holistic medicine appears to be putting this one-dimensional definition of medicine into reverse. We are discovering that, every BODY is different. The absolute relevance and requirement of our unique complex and individual immune system is making a comeback. One size fits all pharmaceutical medicine is no longer seen as the complete answer – “This concept completely ignores the individual human being … that which is pathogenic for one person can be very healthy for another. Standard therapies no longer have a place in chronic diseases” (Hardmouth Immunity and Individuality) Interactions 2025. What has happened to the meaning of medicine?  

In the western world with the coming of the renaissance and modern scientific thinking, propolis, along with many other natural remedies and ideas with their roots in more holistic spiritual concepts disappeared in favour of a more scientific pharmacopeia.

Propolis and Pharmaceutical Medicine  

In practice propolis continued to be used within the subculture of folk medicine in many parts of the world and it was not until the beginning of the 20th century that modern science began to take an interest. We have much to thank our Russian and East European colleagues for this renaissance of interest in evidenced based research. It was not until the 1970s with work in Denmark, France and UK that any significant research was carried out in the so-called West. The 1990’s saw a real surge of interest (See paper produced by Weightman) with academic interest in US, France, UK, Italy and Spain.  

Much of the evidenced that has emerged over the last 35 years has concentrated on trying to fit propolis into the classical one-dimensional pharmaceutical model with its focus on standardised material and key active ingredients and targeted function.  

In Propolis: Natural Healing from the Hive published 25 years ago I reviewed much of the research then available. I concluded then that, despite some encouraging possibilities around CAPE (Caffeic acid phenethyl ester) no single active presented itself as a suitable candidate for pharmaceutical licencing. At the same time, I also suggested that the real efficacy of propolis lay in the mystery of the whole rather than in any single active.   

The mystery of the whole versus the parts

My personal research interest over the last 20 years has turned more and more to this unique mystery and to the mechanism of the whole rather than of the single parts. In 2006 we published a paper illustrating the relationship between climate, chemistry, and biology in propolis. We discovered that propolis from sub-tropical climates was more anti-microbial than propolis from temperate zones. The reason seemed obvious – the beehive was challenged more by bacteria in hot and wet environments and the chemistry of their propolis had to provide an appropriate response to this challenge. Equally obvious, it seemed, was that the local plants must have faced the same challenge and had also adapted and evolved their immune system to meet it. The honeybee in collecting the plants environmental/ecological challenge illustrates the beautiful evolutionary steppingstone that connects the plants immunity into the honeybees.  

Anti versus Pro Bioactivity 

What is not a mystery is that propolis is a veritable symphony of proven bioactivity, a fact which amply corroborates the use and value of propolis in ancient and folk medicines.  Between 30-40 bioactivities have been identified!  These bioactivities are identified classically as pharmacologically ANTI properties – anti bacterial, anti-inflammatory, anti-fungal and so on. The in vitro research which has identified these properties is often used as an indicator their potential to specific diseases.  

The problem is, as we have seen, chemical composition and therefore biological activity vary enormously by climatic zone. How then can we fit propolis as a medicine into a standardised pharmaceutical model.  

The fact is that propolis, this highly complex and variable substance fulfils a primary and holistic role in the hive i.e. as the honeybee unique ecological immune system. It does not differentiate its role into anti-microbial, anti-viral or any other ANTI . Propolis for the beehive has an unequivocally PRO function, balancing, negotiating, supporting and recalibrating in the face of ever-changing challenges. Given this understanding, how do we best develop our research into propolis for the benefit of human beings.

Propolis and human beings 

When we explore the so-called anti- properties of propolis we discover something strange. Propolis does not act primarily as a killer but rather as a negotiator and a balancer. 

  • Research at Oxford UK in 1996 (Calder et al) showed that propolis disabled bacteria i.e. stopped them from joining up and multiplying 
  • Research at Tufts University US 2005 showed how propolis inhibits the quorum sensors which trigger the formation of biofilm. 
  • Research in Keil in Germany 1976 indicated that the flavonoids in propolis effectively inhibited the activity of viruses by sealing up their protein coating preventing them from multiplying

These three examples illustrate how propolis acts not with targeted killing as in the case of antibiotics but by inhibiting and preventing multiplication and in other ways by sealing and disrupting. This is a qualitatively different approach to ANTI medicine. Propolis works as a PRO medicine, an IMS (Immune Support Medicine) sympathetically supporting within the context of the whole i.e. our whole complex and unique immune system 

I close this section by referring to a building and important body of knowledge which is reframing the importance, role and meaning of our immune system. Knowledge which is turning our traditional concepts of medicine on its head.

In Immunity and Individuality Dr Hardtmouth illustrates how our unique gut biome as a key partner with the brain in managing our immune system, thrives on diversity and uniqueness “The more diverse and individual the microbiome colonisation, the better the protection against infections … This result should actually turn our concept of health upside down. It is not the presence of viruses and bacteria that makes the disease, but when certain bacteria are not present” 

James Fearnley is a researcher and manufacturer of natural medicines at Nature’s Laboratory (natureslaboratory.co.uk). In his wider work, he has stimulated social and cultural initiatives exploring the concept of Three-Dimensional Health for individuals (herbalapothecaryuk.com and beevitalpropolis.com), in local communities (thedispensary.org.uk), for companies and organisations (threescompany.info), and for the community at large (beearc.com).

Nature’s Laboratory is a Whitby-based manufacturer and researcher of natural medicines, with a particular focus on herbal medicine and propolis. Combining traditional knowledge with modern scientific research, the company develops and manufactures high-quality natural health products and provides research, product development and manufacturing services to other organisations. It is the parent company of Herbal Apothecary, BeeVital, Sweet Cecily’s and The Whitby Tea Company. Working closely with practitioners, researchers and academic institutions, Nature’s Laboratory is committed to advancing the understanding and use of natural medicines, guided by its principles of balancing economic, social and cultural wellbeing. 

https://natureslaboratory.co.uk

Herbal Apothecary, part of Nature’s Laboratory, is a leading UK manufacturer and supplier of herbal medicines to professional herbal practitioners. Its extensive range includes herbal tinctures, dried herbs, powders, capsules and creams. With a strong commitment to quality, traceability and traditional herbal practice, Herbal Apothecary supports medical herbalists with the medicines and ingredients they need for their clinical work. 

https://herbalapothecaryuk.com